scrooge is the new green, part two: the good grinch
Please consider this a preface, a very important preface, that is, a salient point that you need to remember. We cannot buy parmesan.
$23 for a measly triangle, half of which is rind, and I'm standing on Spring Garden Road wearing a sandwich board that says WILL SMOOCH FOR CHEESE. The same scene plays out repeatedly: I pause in front of the dairy case marked RICH PEOPLE ONLY, PLEASE and sigh eleven times in a row, and then I push my cart over to anything on sale for $1.09. Dented lentils. Week-old iceberg lettuce. Antisocial tuna.
Every Christmas Justin and have that moment. We look at each other and shrug and I say bright green socks from the irregular bin and he says an InStyle magazine from 1998 that I'll swipe from the dentist. And lo! Our gift-swapping expectations are set. So that when I chuck a pair of boxers into his lap on Christmas morning, he's thrilled and touched. And likewise, he surprises me with that combo pack of multi-coloured post-it notes I've been eyeing.
Every Christmas I say the following, with gusto, regarding our children: I really mean it this year. It's going to be small and quiet and Cratchitty. We will make crumbcake. We will braid toilet paper garlands. We will give the children two ice cubes and a flat of corrugated cardboard each.
Every Christmas this gusto softens to I couldn't help it and Justin raises his eyebrows and says Teenaged Mutant Ninja Turtles Shaving Set With Squirtable Neon Cream Soap? and I hang my head and say I also was held at gunpoint in the dollar store in front of a display of Transformer knockoffs and last week I went to Wal-Mart on my way home and all those smiling yellow faces confounded me and I came home with five bags and I don't know how it happened but I'm deeply ashamed not only because of the Third World and corporate America's pillage of the proletariat but also because I am a snob.
How much did you spend? he says.
Only $12.99 per toy, give or take. It'll be good. There will be a mountain. They'll freak.
How many toys?
I calculate. Thirteen battery-operated pieces of shit. One imitation NERF foam rocket set that Ben will probably eat. Two cheap books that I can't stand already. Plastic pretend food that smells like arsenic and comes stamped WHO NEEDS A HEALTHY LIVER WHEN YOU HAVE FRIENDS?
He sighs, anticipating his annual February 12th circuit to the donation bin, the recycling depot, and the dump. So what you're saying is you spent $250 on cheap pieces of shit for the sheer illusion of quantity so that you'll feel like a better parent on the morning of a religious holiday we don't recognize in any other way other than to call it CANDY CANE TIME?
...
...
I stare at Mount Plastmore, enshrouded in crinkled white with red letters that spell VALU.
Right.
+++
We saw our quiet little boy, especially amidst the holiday kerfuffle,
actually forget how to play. He would sit, staring about him
at the massive plastic extravagance,
and not even know where to begin.Where DOES one begin in the midst of a small toy army that plays FOR you?
Well, from my experience from years of working with children—
they either smash it,
or look at it boredly, and watch it do its thing.
The dilemma of the modern child in a nutshell.
I'd like to say it was a Waldorfian Awakening that inspired this year's righteous grinchness. It wasn't.
More so than any other Christmas, the dawn of das spielzimmer made it impossible to contemplate shoving a whole new generation of never-played-with, shrieking, singing, flashing junk into our brand new Grand Central Station Of Fun.
So. Despite being utterly starved of Italian bliss, our Christmas mantra became this: more is less.
There will be no Wal-Mart this year. No aimless wandering through toy departments. No impulse buys. Zero. It's one trip to a good, local toy store for ONE major present for each child, plus stocking stuffers and a book. That's it. All chosen from the kind of high-quality, ethical toys that would usually have me muttering What the f*ck is this, Beverly Hills? and send me beelining for the happy yellow faces.
(The happy yellow faces, and all their ilk, you see, are a trick. You see lower prices, you disregard the film of chemicals and crap and commercialism that clings to everything in there. You want to give your kids a mountain. You binge. Then you purge.)
Not this year. It was NOT EASY.

No mothereffin way. $73 for A TRUCK? Unbefuckinglievable. I circled the shop nine times wringing my hands before buying it, telling the cashier to hurry up before a Scotiabank clerk arrived to put me in chains.
I know. I know. But this is Ben's IT. There is nothing else. He won't notice the lack of mountain. He'll be so thrilled. And you know what? It feels good. Really good.

Until now, lego has gone under the cedar daybed to spawn on its own. This is first time we've ever bought any lego kit for more than $12.99. I stood there staring at the jaunty little price tag on the shelf for a solid three minutes. $69.99. Blink. $69.99. Blink. Still $69.99. Seventy bucks for compromise lego, the actual 'Rock Monster Cave Crusher' rig he wanted sending my wallet into epileptic fits at almost $100 a box.
I know. I know. But this is Evan's IT. There is nothing else. He won't notice the lack of mountain. He'll be so thrilled. And you know what? It feels good. Really good.

Plus pretty much the coolest, very special book ever. I was so captivated, it had to be had. Canadian, my Woozles-veteran mother later informed me. And that's pretty much it. Almost. A copy of Wallace & Gromit's Grand Day Out, found in a bargain bin for $6.99. And a colouring book based on the stories of Oliver Jeffers, all of which we have and love, because I've heard he's, like, totally hot.
Plus some of that candy that explodes in your mouth. That's it.
Plus British marshmallow sticks. Chocolate coins. That's it.
Plus two durable, kid-sized snow shovels, because snow shovelling puts hair on your chest. That's it.
Swear.
+++
More per toy, but less overall. By a long shot. This house is officially declared a Crap Mountain-Free Zone.
More is less.
Except in the case of British marshmallows.
Tuesday, December 8, 2009 in
the learning curve






Reader Comments (43)
BTW, I heard Tim Wynne Jones read a couple of weeks ago. He was FABULOUS. He writes for kids of all ages and was nominated for this year's GG for one of his YA titles. The Zoom books are gorgeous. I was thrilled to see them reissued as a set.
Vivian wants the Lego. Not happening. The books however, I haven't bought yet. Hrm...
As a child, I remember Christmases based on the One Toy that I wanted, and whether or not I got it. I don't remember the other gifts. I didn't care about the other gifts.
There was the year I got my Wrinkles. The year I got my gigantic stuffed Gund dog that I named Rags. There was the year I got the practical joke kit. The year my parents gave me the big plush rabbit puppet with leather lined ears that I called Thumper, who stills sits next to my bed. The year I didn't get the stuffed fawn. The year I got the keyboard.
Every year there is only ever really one present that matters to me, and whether I get it makes or breaks my Christmas.
I hate the trick where the parents leave the desired gift to the last, a la A Christmas Story. Every present I open is merely a disappointment for not being The One Toy, and the final surprise of it at the end is more of a relief than a joy. But if I have received The One Toy I can relax, and enjoy the socks and sweaters and books I have never heard of so much more.
Nowadays it tends to be computer games, instead of stuffed animals.
This year, it's The Sims 3.
Or a baby. But that doesn't seem to be in the offing yet.
Isaac's big gift will be Lego - he has been asking for Star Wars Lego for six months. It's wildly age-inappropriate but it'll be a Christmas afternoon project for him & his dad, so even though the price tag made me cry a little I figured hour for hour, it'll be worth it.
One big toy/item, a book, and a pair of pjs. That's it. I promise. Well, plus stocking stuffers...
We are trying to do the same. My Dad ripped off a NovaNatural doll house for my daughter and we got her some furniture and my son is getting Playmobil. (plus art supplies, skull socks & stocking stuffers...Transformer bandaids & allergen free m&m's)
It feels good. Every year I feel the slightest bit better about how we do. I am SO JEALOUS of your playroom, btw. Someday we will have one. Someday....
I have these good intentions every year but somehow still get sucked into the plastic vortex. At least you're sticking to yours.
Sonny is getting Lego, Eleanor a wooden bed for her doll (I'm busy sewing so many miniature quilts and pillows it looks like Princess & The Pea).
Are British marshmallows really superior? We're flattered.
And what do I really remember from childhood Christmases? The one big toy. Fish tank, BMX bike (wow - how did my single parent mother of six pull that off??). And most of my memories are hazy feel goods about eating Terry's oranges or Smarties and watching movies all day cuddled up on couches as a family.
Well done, Kate.
I too am trying to be near-Grinch like. I've made some things, and will make some more...
Although I did really want that keychain with Peppermint Patty on it for myself.
I love your new room for the boys and your Christmas is sure to be a great one. I went with the less is more approach this year and got the kids an air hockey table, instead of mountains of presents that just get unwrapped and thrown over their shoulders.
I've also done the unthinkable.....created a pile of gifts that have absolutely no purpose and I will bravely and boldly regift them to people who do not have the slightest clue.
Wraping them, I'm still going to wish for a mountain.
But this is better.
I REALLY hope people listen. Last year was a gong show of irritating plastic toys-that-make-noise that I wanted to hide immediately, feeling guilty that people spent hard-earned cash on them, but also just wanting the girls to really enjoy a few good quality things. They have so many years to get wrapped up in the commercialism of it all...
In all seriousness, tremendous post. Every time I read here I think... "now <i>this</i> is a blog!"
Plus their stocking.
And we still end up with a mountain. I hate the mountain. I don't even want, believe in, or strive for a mountain. The concept of "Carnival Christmas" literally makes me feel ill.
So this year, we're trying again to tone it down: fewer things in the stocking, fewer little 'add-on' gifts.
I think you made great choices for your family.
This mountain-reduction process has been my (our) goal for the past few years (first for ourselves and family and now for Felix)...but that makes alot of DAMN PRESSURE to get it right... This year Felix has gotten toys for the plane and I will likely buy him ONE thing...that's it.
PS - Felix has that Sprigg truck (gift last year for Christmas from ME!) it was too early then but he now LOVES LOVES LOVES it. It plays funky music when you push it and says "Jumbo"...what's not to love?
My first Christmas at my inlaws almost killed me. They definitely believe in the mountain mentality and we were opening tubes of toothpaste among other things, just so there were lots of things to open. My brain almost split open. We grew up with very few presents under the tree--usually a 'big' family gift, a book or music, and something else. It wasn't because my parents believed in the less-is-more, but because we were poor.
Last year, there were more presents from grandparents than from us or Santa (Santa only delivers one toy per person). I really don't know what to do about them and how much they love plastic loud toys. I've slowly been removing those toys, but I hate the cycle of it all. On one hand I think--it's okay, they get pleasure from giving these things--but then I think of off-gassing and carbon footprints and, and, and....sigh.
But back in the day, when they were younger, and we were still an "intact" family, I worked for an educational toy company, and the best of those (expensive) toys went under the tree. There were no mountains, but there were toys that were played with for years. Toys that my two teenagers still remember fondly. Toys that they shared with younger cousins, and the children of friends when they visited. Maybe they wanted an excuse to revisit these toys without seeming uncool, or maybe they wanted to pass on the joy, either way, it was clear that these toys were valued more highly than any Wal-mart trash they had ever received.
We also had a playroom, with shelves. No toy-boxes, and very few baskets. Lots of shelves they could reach, and this kept the mess down to a minimum. Toys were easy to find, and easy to replace at the end of the day.
I think you'll be quite happy with your recent choices. Can't wait to hear how it all goes down on the big morning.
We try to ask the grandparents for gifts that are things we can do as a family, like renewing our zoo and Children's Museum memberships, to further reduce the mountain. We've asked this every year and this is the first time my in-laws are actually going along with it. Or so they say. We'll see what they throw in at the last minute.
Wondering if the posterboard worked because I've just penned one: Will Smooch for Organic Egg Nog because my husband LOVES the stuff even if it goes so fast and aren't there raw eggs in there?
we are doing one joint present - a two sided easel - that i already gave them because i needed PEACE already, dammit - and they LOVE it! one biggish present each - a little ride on thing for hy and an imaginext space station thing for porter, and a little gift each - a bakugan and a babydoll. They will get PJ's and some stocking stuffer mm's but that is about all from us. i feel better about this. instead of the many crappy little things. and my brain is-a-hummin over the playroom. i am already planning it...
I loved it.
While my Gordon and I do not have children, we are often overwhelmed by the "mountain" of Christmas stuff, wrap, and waste. We have requested family time or donations to charities over gifts - sometimes we are heard, sometimes not. So we do our best: Santa delivers us stockings only and Christmas morn we make an online donation together to a charity of choice. It's a great tradition we started a couple of years ago. (This year we're doing Smile Train.)
I really enjoyed your writing voice, and will happily bookmark your blog and return.
I hope you and yours have a peaceful and enjoyable holiday season.
~ Tracy
But Z's One Gift this year was the Mindstorm Lego robot; if only you could have seen his ectastic face, it was worth every penny of the $279 I put on Ye Olde CC.