what was planted to heal the world
I imagine a being with a crystal ball trained on the parallel universe in which Liam survived. He might have been gay, you know, the being says. He might have been gay. Does that change anything?
I am his mother. He is my son.
Please, give me my baby back, just as he was.
+++++
Sorry.... she hisses, trolling my friend's grassroots campaign against a constitutional ammendment to ban gay marriage in Arizona. Marriage is a special and sacred covenant designed by God to be between a MAN and a WOMAN!
She invokes God to insist that only her kind of life is ordained. She puts conditions on human brothers and sisters, on me and on you. She denies love, that special and sacred gift designed to heal the world.
And so I reply Yes. Heterosexuals are God's chosen people, and all the rest are damned. Wait... no. White christian heterosexuals. That's it. Actually... no. White christian heterosexuals who remain married and never divorce for any reason nor cheat on taxes, tests or vows. And they must be fertile, and they must choose to have children. And they must love their neighbours and never indulge conceit. These are God's special and sacred people and anyone not among them - by choice, fate or birth - deserves damnation.
Indeed, the very definition of a christian ideal.
My congratulations to you on presumably being among the chosen few, at least on paper, which I hope is enough to facilitate a sound sleep.
+++++
In the muscle-memory of our souls we've all been marginalized. Each and every one of us has had miserably timed turns at being poor, or protestant, or mentally ill, or black, or differently abled, or female, or jewish, or iroquois, or gay.
In all those states we were born as a living, breathing expression of hope and renewal and love just as we were. In all those states we have been denied by each other.
Too many of us forget to remember.
+++++
A baby dribbles cereal for the first time and we think oh! look at you go. Funny feeling, isn't it? Good boy! and at that moment he is a hairline closer to making his own way in the world.
Then he crawls like greased lightening. Then he weeble-wobble walks. Then before we know it he's got the keys to the car and we hear the voice of our parents from our own mouths: it's not you I'm worried about. It's all the other drivers and we won't sleep a wink that night until we know he is safe in his bed.
Parenthood is one long letting-go. Our children grow up, up and away, and they need us less and less, and there's no use in resisting it, and that's just how it's meant to be.
Now step back. Way back.
The collective of human beings doesn't grow up, up and away. As we grow up - as we fumble to feel around the edges of this world we've been given - those edges close in. The world gets smaller, and rather than growing away we grow increasingly squashed together.
There's no longer enough space to remain cloistered in like-minded tribes. We bump and jostle, forced by sheer proximity and exposure to look at each other - really look - and exist among the unfamiliar scents and sounds and fashions of others.
In this cacophony there are now only two breeds of humans.
There are those who grimace and whine quit shoving! You stink. I'm better than you. And you, too. Shut up. Move over. He stepped on my foot! Asshole. I'll show you. This is unbearable. This is wrong. This has to stop.
And there are those who shrug, knowing this is how it was always meant to happen.
I suppose ten million years from now, we'll all be just alike
same colour, same kind
and working together
and maybe we'll have all of the fascists out of the way by then
This growing together, this sharing space: it is as sure as tide, current in a bottleneck. To push against it is masochistic and misguided, inevitable failure proven time and time again. To turn the other way and surf it is the joy, the awakening that was designed for us.
+++++
I held my baby son as he died.
Read this, the whole thing, and I think you'll understand:
I always suspected that deep down inside the person yammering on about unconditional love was really trying to set himself up to get a piece of ass. Nothing wrong with that, but don't kid yourself about unconditional love. Until you've lived it, you can't know it. And the separation between those who can grasp the concept and those who have held the feeling is a yawning chasm that nothing but experience can bridge.
Until you love your child without ever knowing whether or not you'll ever get to hold her, you don't know unconditional love. Until your love for your child is greater than your need for her to live even one more day with anything less than the dignity she deserves, you don't know unconditional love.
Having been there - urgently, desperately - witnessing condemnation turns me inside out. How dare anyone put conditions on love - that which was planted to heal the world by the very God they invoke?
+++++
Imagine a being with a crystal ball trained on the future of the child you hold in your arms. The child with the jack ‘o lantern grin, the succulent, cheesy neck, the chubby folds. The child that woke up twice last night in hot tears and needed you, just you.
She's going to be gay, you know, the being says. She's going to be gay and she's going to live far away but she'll be home every summer and for Christmas with her wife. She's going to be happy, and smart, and ordinary, and gay. Does that change anything?
Beg, plead: Just keep her safe and whole. I will love her forever, just as she is.
Thursday, October 23, 2008 in
brain dumps










Reader Comments (76)
Yes.
You beautiful, amazing, soulful woman - you humble me and honor all of us with your words. Thank you, from the bottom of my heart. I would love your permission to repost this all over the place (but specifically on the No On 102 blog - really, it's too good not to share). I wish everyone would read this, especially that last part. You made me cry.
One correction though - Prop 102 is not to make gay marriage illegal. Same sex marriage is already illegal in Arizona (and in all other states except for Ca, MA and CT) Prop 102 seeks to make it double illegal by amending the constitution to state that marriage can only be between one man and one woman (so those wishing to marry goats, pigs and turtles of any gender need not apply). This way, if there ever exists federal legislation to legalize same sex marriage - Arizona can't stick their fingers in their ears and say "Na, na, na, na - we're not listening"
Seriously, in the midst of an economic crisis - this warrents 9 million in funds raised by the right wingers to get this bill passed?? I wonder how that money could have been spent....hmmmm....
In California, where same sex marriage has been legal for a few short months - Prop 8 has the potential to make it illegal again. And the money raised there by the conservative side makes Arizona's Yes On 102 bank balance look like pocket change.
We need allies on this fight - and I'll take one as wise, beautiful and eloquent as you any day. Welcome aboard.
Makes my home country look better and better.
Jeanette
Your words of love are now reverberating in the cosmos, into the soul of Liam even. :)
xoxo
peace.love.free
This just made me stop, go back, and read again. This is so true. So beautiful.
Why do we care so much about denying things to people? Denying the concept of love because "they're not like us, when we don't actually know what love means. Well, most of us don't, I'm afraid.
Beautiful words.
How other's cannot see clearly enough to wish only happiness and fulfillment on their children-I can't and won't understand that. So long as she brings home someone who loves her for her-I'm good.
I've had people get confused and bemused when I use both genders to speak of their possible future loves-but it's only true-I don't decide these things, and when the time comes, I want to only know of their joy, period.
My parents had love, and lost. Life is far far far too short.
Thank you for all the wonderful things you say. You truly are magnificent in the way you capture life with your words.
John 34
"A new command I give you: Love one another. As I have loved you, so you must love one another. By this all men will know that you are my disciples, if you love one another."
Have you looked your beliefs in the EYE? Studied them, read the Bible, the Talmud, held it up against something other than your own mirror? I am proud when I finish 3 loads of laundry in a day, how can I then look into that and try to access a god?!
That is faith, to understand that we can't understand everything. Read The Sparrow, which deals with this SO eloquently, without stepping on the hems of particular faiths, Marie Doria Russell manages to say what I want to so badly but never seem to. David's writing is so true and Kate, can I be your first baptist girl to say that I love gay people? I do! To do less would be to disobey the command given in scripture by the very Jesus I love with my whole heart, the one that loves each and every one of us...even when we deny Him.
Thank you, Kate
They are never too young to learn acceptance - that's what I believe. Teach my kids about equality at school because that's what I'm teaching them at home.
There are certain things that I just do not get and this is one of those things. Why are some people threatened by this?
I honestly don't get it. Did you notice when Scott Brison, Liberal Member of Parliament, got married a year or two ago in Cheverie, up near the Fundy Shore? The wedding was attended by a Who’s Who of Canadian politics, including former Prime Ministers Paul Martin and Joe Clark, former US ambassador (and New Brunswick Premier) Frank McKenna, and former Montreal Canadiens goalie and NHL Hall of Famer (and MP and published author) Ken Dryden.
Canada is but one of two or three countries that sanctioned gay marriage a few years ago... and... then... wait for it... nothing... happened...
The four horsemen of the apocalypse aren't riding down Lincoln Street. Toronto's Gay Pride Parade hasn't been dragging people off the street and making them gay. No telemarketers have called me offering a free toaster and begging me to switch teams.
You are seeing this with your heart, and like the little fox, it is with the heart that one sees rightly.
my MIL just left from a visit with us. she was watching the news and going on about how gay marriage is an "abomination". She has one granddaughter who is bisexual and one who is gay. I never understood how she can say she loves them and then say those terrible things.
This is why we hurt in the world - because people can't leave well enough alone and let everyone just BE ... BE who they are meant to BE.
it really is just about love and not taking it away. ever. for any reason. it is so hard to get in the first place. let us foster and keep it any way we can.
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/g/a/2008/05/16/notes051608.DTL&feed=rss.mmorford
Like everyone else who have already posted, I just don't know why folks don't want other folks just to find love and happiness. Also, I'd *love* to see the proposed lesson plans on how the kids are going to be taught to be gay!(Maybe it would lead to a better-dressed populace? What's so wrong about that?)
Also, I'm so glad I'm rubbin' up against the likes of you, Kate. ;)
I'm so glad I was raised by open-minded parents, and my heart aches for my gay friends who have to lie or pretend to their families.
You got me to thinking about this category of religious resistence that’s tied up with a neat, absolving bow in the form of this: “I love gay people because I love all people, just like Jesus did—even the sinners. Because as christians, we don’t hate the sinner, we hate the sin.”
Thinking out loud: my problem is that righteous hate is righteous hate. Making a distinction between the purported sin and the purported sinner… I feel like that’s only to make disapproval more palatable for believers uncomfortable being seen as bigots—so that they can say they accept gay people, but just not gay sex. Really, it’s the same judgement, damnation and condemnation with a loving smile on the front of it...
on that note, why does gay sex upset people so much, anyway? I wonder what I'd get if I googled that. I'd probably have to pay.
Black Hockey Jesus, hey thanks… I’m going to do my best despite teh pretzel brain. What I meant by humanity ‘growing up’ was not population growth, but sophistication, learning, science, increased separation of church and state (theoretically speaking.. hmph), basic human rights, democracy, free speech. And by ‘world gets smaller’ I mean exposure (media, internet) rather than literal space, although what you say is totally true too. So I dunno. That’s a whole ‘nother post.
Jen, how true of the carving from plastic. And as much as I love to hear from a Baptist girl who loves gay people, it only makes me more deeply curious. Are you okay with gays loving each other in the ordinary, emotional and physical ways we feel entitled to express love to one another as heteros? I don’t mean to challenge you, I’m just genuinely curious if you really can be a student of scripture and also subscribe to love without conditions. I can’t tell you how much I hope you say yes, because that would give me hope, but hey, no pressure. (grin)
(to everyone: all of the above of course is meant with the gentlest respect in the world, the kind that comes across so much better in kitchens and in front of woodstoves than it does on this here ticky-tapper.)
Don't have the words to tell you how brimful of beauty I find your words.
Crying.
I think the gay thing is misunderstood to the Nth degree in the christian community. It is not a choice. Do I accept "gay love"? I am not interested in stopping it... I don't believe being gay is an excuse for a sleep with anyone and everyone lifestyle, though. I also don't believe it was intended. Plain science proves my point but people move beyond plain science, don't they. Can two adults of same sex love each other the way me and my husband love each other? Absolutely.
Baptist as we may be we have many close friends who are gay and we love them just as they are. I have no interest in trying to "change" them. I think that is THE most ridiculous concept in the religious world. When I decided to be a full fledged Christian my best friend (who is gay) asked me a similar question. My response? I just want people to get to know Jesus, not to use being gay and "christian" jerks as an excuse to not figure Him out. Look it in the eye, as I said, and you and Him work out all the details.
We have had gay people in our Bible study even, same response. I can't wait to get to heaven and ask God, "Lord you made the Bible say this, what did you really mean and you made people and they feel this and I'm confused, but aren't they GREAT just like me, messed up just like my little white, baptist, heterosexual heart? Am I wrong just loving them just like they are? Cause I do God."
So there, as honest as I can be... I really do love gay people and not because I have to. I just do, how they are, where they are. I am not okay with drag queens who don't shave and gay cowboys for the record, the hats twisting and turning and hands in the back of each others wranglers, girlfriends back in the mobile homes...uck! (sorry to any offended gay cowboys or brokeback fans)
With all sincere love to all of you... Jen
Nothing would eve change the love I have for my girls. I tell them that al the time.
as a woman who has been so very in love with another woman for the past three years, despite thinking that she would always marry a man, my heart breaks a little bit every day thinking about the blind hatred for those who can't understand.
we're all just the same, at the core. a group of cells, multiplying and dividing until skin forms and then a heart and some lungs and some eyes with which to see the world.
thank you for this post.
The husband and I talk, on occasion, about how life would be different if Jack was gay. The kid is 6 months old, so this won't be an issue for a long time, but if it is . . . Oh, I hope by the time it is, he would be able to get married. He would not be marginalized. He would not feel lesser, or other, or like he had to hide from a large section of the population (which would unfortunately include his maternal grandparents.)
I also wonder what is so scary about homosexual love. I can never get someone who thinks it is a sin to talk about it deeply. I would love to have that conversation, without ire, with passionate but measured and considered responses. It's proven impossible thus far.
And gay cowboys? Are you kidding me? Your description of ‘hands in the back of each others’ wranglers’ was, like, totally HOT. (wink) My two cents... Brokeback was representative of being a gay cowboy in the poor and rural 60s. You couldn’t *not* get married, even if it was the antithesis of who you would otherwise be, and there’s no rug big enough in christendom that will keep inherent gayness at bay for a lifetime. That’s my guess, anyway. Sad for the wives, but equally for the needlessly tortured men. And to close off: Wrangler-on-wrangler love. And now for a moment of silence.
Leigh, I’m totally happy that you commented, absolutely. I’m glad you’re here, and that you’re grey... although I believe the only choice we make is to either be true to ourselves, or to stifle ourselves for fear of what other people will think (which I’ve seen people try to do, and often ends in destructive behaviour at worst and depressing unfulfillment at best... who wants to live an inauthentic life?). Perhaps you chose your husband because that’s who you are, in this life.. on the spectrum, you're far enough on the straight side so that living as you do feels comfortable for you, like me. I couldn’t agree with you more, though, that heterosexuals have it easy in terms of living in their skin, and gay people don’t—they have to fight and transform and confess and sacrifice in order to be who they are. And for that, I can only respect them that much more.
Thanks both of you, thank you so much for delving a little more deeply. Too often, a continued, gentle conversation is shut down, and I think it’s such a gift when it doesn’t.
I am a C. I am a CH. I am a CHRISTIAN. (sorry, childhood song that got stuck in my head as I'm writing this). And apparently, due to the lovely descriptiveness that I was unable to put into words, live in shades of gray. Having read the Scripture, my understanding or reconciliation or "how I let it sit in my head so I can sit through church" is that those passages often thrown around to condemn homosexuality are really more applicable to adultery. Don't have willy nilly (ahem) sex with anyone. More importantly though, for me, is God's love. And to me, the lesson is to share that love with everyone - gay or straight or somewhere in between.
But, like a previous poster said, I can't wait for that conversation with Him to see what it really all means. Until then, I practice the love.
Kate I get what you are saying but I have to stick to the fact that there are ways things were intended... but they can get rather messed up like you said. The male G spot though, hmmm... how do we get to all these places on your blog, needless to say I am addicted! :) Much love Kate, you are precious!
thanks,
There is only one small distinction I'd like to make here, and it's this: not all heterosexuals have it easy living in their skin with respect to the gender spectrum. Ask any hetero, closeted cross dresser if it's easy and I bet you'll get a resounding, "HELL NO! It effing sucks." Or a man who was born in a female's body and is struggling with how to come to terms with that. Or any other person who doesn't quite fit on the traditional hetero spectrum, but who isn't gay, either.
But truly, truly, this was a beautiful post. I can't thank you enough for your gorgeous writing-- nothing has made me think so much in a long time.
I do not want my children to grow up to be anything than what they are, were meant to be.
Your blog leaves me gasping for air.
Thank you for being here.
i don't know, now i kind of feel like i'm rambling, but this has been an awesome discussion.
These are the kinds of things that make me cry when I think of the grumpy judgmental people who think they have a right to say who can be married. They probably want my son in an institution anyway, not living in the community and falling in love with a woman or a man. ACK! People! Please, please let's change the world. Please, please help me make it a place that accepts all of our kids, smart or retarded, gay or straight. Sorry, I'm just blubbering now. Big puddles of tears should not be allowed keyboards. Off to blow my nose.
And so grateful for all the support and love within this post.
We're surrounded by supporters of this horrible proposition here in CA and all the hate I feel emanating from it but still, touched and pleased to find support from someone who is not obligated to give it.
Leigh, you're not rambling at all. All very true. I just get uppity when people put the word "choice" next to the word "sexuality" because most often, it means "you should have chosen to be straight instead of gay, because gayness and godliness cannot coexist, so just DON'T BE GAY."
There's a huge segment of people that still cling to the belief that we choose our sexualities - because as long as they do, they can believe that homosexuality is an abhorrence, unnatural and wrong. They want to believe that gay people are sinners by choosing to indulge in gay sex, and by not being strong enough (presumeably) to make 'tough' or 'selfless' or 'godly' decisions. Because if they accept that we're made just as we are - that we are born gay or straight or anything in between - then they have to accept that God made us all these colours, all these shades of grey. And that would mean they'd have to accept people different from themselves, and that would be ICKY.
So that's why I take a black-and-white viewpoint - only as a knee-jerk reaction to the black-and-white viewpoint on the other side. They say it's a choice because they want to condemn it, and I say we're born wired one way or the other because I believe everyone deserves love and respect.
What you say is fair too, assuming I'm reading you right, all your greys.
KYouell, indeed! Yes. Yet another angle on all this... thank you.
As for being hard-wired gay. I dunno, no DNA scientist here, but I am a hard-wired shoe slut, so anything is possible (I will do ANYTHING for a good pair of shoes) But I do have a Ph.D in the investigation of the Heart. In my own experience, we love people. We fall in love with people and CHOOSE to be with those people or not. Perhaps some kinds of packages make our bits a tad juicier than others (okay kate, i just put your blog on Parental Discretion lists). But we do choose.
I think we fall in love with. are attracted to, want to sleep with: people. I don't think there are "kinds" of people, there are just people. And we, as people, should be able to marry who we love (among many other things, we need to be valued as humans to make our own choices) We have too many spirals of experience just in our wee short span on earth. Some people will love the same gender the whole time they are here. Some may the last 5 years. Some, smack in the middle. Who knows. Who cares? Really, I only care about who I love, not who anybody else loves. I celebrate that we all want to love! What a sweet species we are! so capable! Love! I have certainly loved women before, but I live in partnership and parentship with a man. The labels we methodically stick upon ourselves and others, the containers we create to stuff our massive beings in, the generalizations we have, the judgments we utter in our hearts. yuck. icky. poopoo. Do Unto Others. (unless others make different choices than us of course).
It's such a mind boggling issue of Church in bed with the State, of course, a beginning of time problem that just won't.go.away. Fundamentalist Christians, Rastafarians, Muslims have EVERY RIGHT to CHOOSE to be homophobic in their religious dogma (i have my own opinion on their opinion, but that is neither here nor there) But that religious practice should not regulate State law. Ohmygod. This is what we have been facing. Judeo-Christian ideology regulating how we live as social creatures. I am nothing and yet someone else spiritual practice is placed upon me and I am expected to make those decisions based on their belief system. Scaaaary. Big time Boogieman.
Compassion. Peace. Humility. Authenticity. Love. I'll end my rant there.
(thanks for the space to 'brain dump')
mb
just when i think I can't love you more...you go ahead and write something like that. and so. i love. you. more.
j.