calculated risk
I haven’t talked to her in ages, this friend from high school. She calls and says Howthehellareya? I’ve been thinking of you, and wondering how you are. You popped into my head, so I had to call and see if you had any news!
My stomach sinks at her cheer. Does she think I’m still pregnant, wondering if the babies have come yet?
I say Uhh... that depends on what you already know.
Well, she replies, I heard you had them, and one of them’s okay and one of them’s not.
Right. Well, one of them died, I say, feeling suddenly awkward and adding unnecessarily, the sick one.
Oh! she says distantly, the perkiness of her voice unbroken. Well I’m sorry to hear that.
I’m not particularly keen on filling the silence that follows, but I’m obliged to, stumbling yes, he was my son, and he’d had brain damage, and he died. And it’s been a horrible couple of months, and now here we are.
She says did you have, like, a funeral or something?
And I say no, we did it. His ashes, I mean. We found a place.
And she says oh.
The conversation stalls, suddenly unwanted by both of us. Like being at a Bill Lynch fairground and getting to the front of the Scrambler lineup just in time to see a kid puke at the height of the spin cycle. The instant deflation of ugghhh… nevermind.
Ben stirs and so we hang up, saying okay, well, we’ll have to go out for lunch sometime, and I am struck by the vastness of the gulf between me and her.
I did check out your ahh… blog, she’d said. I don’t understand it. I just wanted to see what happened, without having to ahh… read it all.
Good, then — I doubt she’ll read this. I hope not, because her unaffectedness is prompting this post, in which I’m about to use the word ‘pussy’ in a derogatory manner. And in a way which might piss you off a bit too, make you think me a blowhard. Consider yourself warned.
At the risk of being tiresomely ‘us and them’-ish, she got me thinking about The Footloose, the Voluntarily Child-Free Camp. Those that go on wine-tasting tours and who don’t eat supper (a.k.a. microwaved fishsticks and frozen corn) at 4:30 and who don’t have cesarean muffintops and who must think us breeders and our snot-nosed rabble as nothing more than sweatpant-wearing, poop-obsessed frumps.
Pleased with themselves in their tidy, sexy void, in which nobody does the “WE DID IT, WE DID IT, WE DID IT, YAAAY!” song and dance number after success with a trusty backpack and companion Boots the Monkey.
F*cking pussies.
You think you’re living, really living, revelling in a life that’s all about you. Sure, you’re living my momentary fantasy: perky tits and sleeping in and jogging and international travel and sharp-edged coffee tables.
But you’re still a bunch of pussies.
Now Kate, squeaks my near-inaudible, microscopic-sized inner rational self. Everything is relative. Get a hold of yourself and your inferiority complex. Be cooler than this.
But no. I need you to hear how intense this life can be, how immense it is, this vertigo, how blindingly terrifying it is to love this much, to hold pure human energy in your hands. To have it evoke such frantic wanting in you, and hope, and fear, and joy.
You don’t just say Gee, ya lost one, too bad! with all the weightiness of Betty Boop.
You’ll be hit by the mack truck of mamahood, if you’re fortunate. And during some endless, nightless night your child’s eyeballs will roll back into his head in milky bliss and you might remember me, your old friend from high school whose baby died, and you might remember talking to me on the phone and feeling like, totally weirded out.
And suddenly, you’ll understand.
++++++++
This is not intended to provoke heckles towards the unnamed. She really is lovely, and lively in that infectious way. Today, it didn’t fit. But I can’t fault her for being unable to grasp the loss of something she has yet to experience. And I don’t mean to invalidate the life paths of others, chosen or not.
I hesitate with this post — for the above reason and also because some of my favourite people are in this camp, child-free by census but not lacking in empathy.
It’s just strange to fail to relate this to someone, the intensity of the past two months. And I have to come here to you, my comrades, to say and she’s like blablabla, and then I was like, yadda yadda and she was like, SHUT UP! and she, like, TOTALLY didn’t get it, and doesn’t that seem, like, kind of effed-up to you?
++++++++
Ben is on my lap as I write this, and he just tooted, and I am totally whipped.
And my muffintop is wearing sweatpants.
Just an FYI.


Reader Comments (126)
Right, back to the intensity.
(And in related news.. would you ever...? http://rootsofempathy.org)
I'm so sorry on behalf of your ''friend''; in my head I give people miles of leeway because there are no right words to say when a child dies.
But in my heart, everytime I had to ''explain'' that, no, it wasn't as easy as, ''Oh. You can always have another one!'' and hey, thanks for making Jackson a non-person who doesn't even count, it killed my soul.
Ugh. I'm sorry again, making this about me. I'm terribly sorry your friend was unkind and indifferent. Liam deserves better.
I remember a Jaclyn Smith (?) commercial. She was hawking a perfume, I think, and her line was, "My father told me, sometimes the art of being a woman is knowing when NOT to be too much of a lady." That just seems to apply to phone calls like the one you got.
*HUGS*
I also love how you needed to relate this story to us - not just as a journal and blog post, but as a rant of 'and then she said, and then i said'... maybe you need us as much as we all seem to need you?
In any case, thanks for sharing - and once again being so honest. I do think that is why I keep coming back - even when we haven't met - is that your honesty continues to surprise and delight me.
My heart goes out to your family. Do know that there are others who understand, about motherhood, blogging, loss, love, and the need to tell it like it is.
I wouldn't have had that response.
I am impressed by the thoughtfulness and the sensitivity of your post and response here--you know, not wanting to start an angry mob and all.
Also, I'm for getting in as many curses as you can.
Just for the record.
i've never understood those conversations, not at all. why someone would choose to call only to then turn into a perky sunbeam of superficiality...to make themselves impossible for someone in ANY kind of pain to relate to? i wonder what they think it is that they're doing? cheering you up? bah.
i will say that it was a childless friend, for me, who tried the hardest to be frank and sensitive and supportive...which i still appreciate more deeply than i can tell her.
cheers to your muffin-top, friend, and all it has made of you.
I'm so glad Ben is home. It is so good to hear you talk about baby toots and muffin tops!
Your kindness trumps ignorance.
The scent of "Clive Christian" could never be as sweet as Bens "toot"
Enjoy this day =)
"I heard you had them, and one of them's okay, and one of them's not."
Stupid, insensitive woman. Childless or not, there's no excuse for this complete lack of sensitivity. If she had even an ounce of emotional judgement, she would have called a mutual friend. Or, as someone else pointed out, taken a moment out of rearranging her wardrobe to read your blog.
I stumbled across your exquisitely written pages a couple of months ago and I've cried plenty of times but never felt ready or eloquent enough to post. Well, I'm ready now. Fuck her, indeed.
I sometimes think back on my child-free days and am ashamed at how incredibly selfish and self-centered I was. Being a mother has been the source of my greatest joys and my deepest pains. I really do feel sorry for women who dont know what it's like-it's that intense.
Life is hard, and inspires vertigo no matter where in its crazy spectrum you are. And I am sick of mothers thinking the rest of us don't get it. To simplify my life as all wine tours is to miss out entirely, too.
You think that because I am childless I do not understand loss? Or to love like that? Meh. Think whatever you want. I have had experiences, too, that I pray you never have.
To feel isolated, I think, is the human condition. To feel that those who haven't gone through cannot know. It's just not true.
Those barriers are exacerbated by the ugly polite, the knowing only what NOT to say (don't act too upset, dear god, don't ask about her feelings). Women, especially, grit their teeth and smile as if it'll pull them through.
But they are the same chemicals that run through your brain as the ones that run through mine. Empathy is not a mistake, it's there by mechanics, by design. Through your words, imperfect as they may be (and wonderful, too) we can live this human thing together.
I wonder if people will hate this. They may. I am sorry, if you do.
Since having my Ben and Jacqueline, I am often overwhelmed by the awesome vulnerability that comes along with loving them so intensely. Your post rings so true, which is why I come back here multiple times a day...you express that mamalove in a way that I cannot.
Kate, you're awesome. Muffintop Mommas of the world unite!
another muffintop momma here.
i know the love you speak of...the one that is too much to handle when you actually stop to think about it.
you got some lucky boys...
Well put muddy, I hear you.
I know as I write that child-free life isn't carefree - Justin andI had that life for more than ten years before having Evan. And I used to look at parents and think to myself, "What makes them think they're so enlightened just because she squeezed out a couple of mini-mes?"
And now I'm one of them (and just as irrational as ever). Just know that by reducing your life to wine-tasting vacations, I'm being deliberately ridiculous for the sake of exploring how it feels to now be on the other side of the gulf.
I don't *really* think your life is easier. Sometimes, it just feels that way.
Thanks for your comment.
Motherhood doesn't make us better people, just brings out what was there already, raw and unvarnished.
You don't know me at all ..I'm Rob Girad's wife Karen.I just read your last post and I'm shaking I'm so mad.. Pussy excellent choice of words!This has nothing to do with childlessness... my 5 year old niece would have more empathy!The only thing I can think of to make any sense of her direct coldness, is the possibility she had no idea what to say. By making light of the situation she was not trying to bring you down. ( in her own head maybe thought this was the best approach)My dad was in an accident when I was 18 and died suddenly and I noticed people with the best intentions.. just did not know what to say. They would avoid me like a feak show ..not because they did not love me they just had no idea how to handle the situation.You are strong and wonderful with three beautiful children. One who just is in another place.Let's face it when you are 25 spending $200 on jeans drinking cosmo's buying $20 cheese... very cool. Once you get in your 30's just kind of lame and lonely.. ( yes that's a dig)
Where you have two boys who adore you..a fabulous husband ..and hey that muffin top will be gone in a few months.. and you will have a flat stomach and a family that admires and adores you.. and I'm sure a few Cosmo's on the side!
I have to agree with this poster. Sometimes I feel like an alien when I tell a mother I don't have children. And I hate the enevitable question "why", with that smirky "I'm better than you" look. Did you ever stop to think that maybe we don't have a choice in the matter. The fact that I don't have children doesn't make me an unfeeling, happy-go-lucky, do-what-I-want-when-I-want person either. I work around 60 hours a week and the rest of the time I have is spent taking care of a 48 year old man with brain damage. As far as I'm concerned, having children is a walk in the park and a blessing and I might think I'm a lot of things, but I'm not a pussy.
So what I'm trying to say is that it is effed up that she wasn't willing to come along on the journey by reading some of your words about it.
To all of the "non-mothers" why is it you feel the need to have us “mothers” recognize you and set you apart?? Everyone is different some people learn form experience and others from watching. I am sorry you couldn’t see in that post right after the words she spoke how she tried her best to explain… But then again who am I to go off on a tangent this long?
I love your blog, Kate, and my heart goes out to you and your family. Thank you for sharing such a personal saga with us. More people than you'll ever know grieve for Liam.
I'm sorry your friend was clueless and (unintenionally) cruel, but even as someone who's not "intentionally childless" (I'd trade my flat stomach and carefree single lifestyle for a family in an instant, given the choice) it hurts to see your arrows aimed at the not-mamas of the world, even though I know the arrows were defensive ones.
And I'd never look down on anyone for eating fish sticks for dinner. :)
But you’re still a bunch of pussies."
--AMEN. Motherhood is astonishingly difficult.
i loved the perky tits line, it's my biggest beef with all that happens in this process. God, why did you take those away from me? I had an awesome rack.
I've had to learn, even though I'm a mother, how to react to the loss of a child by a friend. I had to remove the instant fear and horror at the idea of losing one of my own children and just be there to love and support my friend in HER grief. Her horrific reality.
Life is a continuous lesson in giving rather than taking.
I have a 2-year-old son and you can call me a pussy anytime--I haven't been where you've been, or close to it. But I surely do feel a deep, empathic connection to you.
My two-cents' worth on today's post: I think it's more of a some/others than an us/them binary, if it's a binary at all...some, like your friend on the phone (and childless or not), fly by without touching the ground often enough.
But we all need artificial binaries every now and then in order to get our minds around something, around something difficult. So we can muddy ourselves without getting too muddled.
The thing about motherhood--about parenthood, generally--is what you've pin-pointed in your post, exactly: the necessary escape from deep narcissism. Unless you're Rebecca Eckler, that is.
All best wishes (from someone who wishes she, too, were back in the Maritimes),Triny Finlay
I don't have children, by choice, because I'm not at a place in my life where I would want to be for a child. Although if one came a long, I would be ecstatic. I do not think this makes me oblivious to pain and suffering. Nor does I think it makes me any better than the women I know who have decided to wander into middle age and beyond without children, by choice. One thing my profession has shown me is that I would much rather have someone acknowledge their limitations than have something - a marriage, a mortgage, a baby - when they aren't willing to sacrifice what is necessary to ensure the amount of work towards a healthy relationship (and especially, a life dependent on them).
A sacrifice it is, and a beautiful one, and one that makes my uterus ache with anticipation. But even if it didn't ache and never fills, I like to think that I would still relate to your struggle on a human level. Single twenty-something with no children and perky (if teeny tiny) tits.